Uptown Saint John seafood pie

For a Maritimer, seafood and Christmas go hand in hand. It’s not that we don’t eat fish and seafood the other eleven months of the year; we do! At Christmas time it’s different. We honour the bounty of the sea that surrounds us. For many of us, it is the meal of Christmas eve.

This simple pie is one of my family’s favorites. Simple in technique but precious in the ingredients! Succulent Digby scallops and deep water Bay of Fundy lobster napped in a cheddar cream sauce with dollops of whipped creamed potatoes and sprinkled with grated Sussex cheddar cheese. When I work with seafood, I feel grounded and attached to my ancestors who chose to settle on the rugged shores of the Bay of Fundy. I know that sounds lofty but I get romantic at this time of the year!  I wrote the recipe from this house in Uptown Saint John hence the name…

Uptown Saint John Seafood Pie

Serves 4

Preheat oven 400*F

4 russet potatoes, peeled, cut in quarters and placed in a pot of cold water

1.5 lbs fresh lobster meat – you can substitute with jumbo shrimp

1 lb fresh Digby scallops, healed – you can substitute with any scallop you can find

1 cup whipping cream

1/4 cup whole milk

2 tablespoons butter

1 clove of garlic, minced

1/3 cup chopped red bell pepper

1/2 teaspoon sea salt – to taste

1/2 teaspoon ground white pepper

1/4 teaspoon cayenne pepper

2 cups cheddar cheese, grated

Boil potatoes until fork tender then drain and whip with 2 tablespoons of whole milk – make sure the potatoes are creamy which may require more milk but don’t make them mucky

While potatoes are boiling, melt butter in a large skillet over medium heat

Add chopped peppers and minced garlic, saute for 3 minutes

Add scallops and saute 1 minute then add lobster meat, cream and whole milk

Heat to just before a boil, reduce heat and add 1 1/2 cups of grated cheddar cheese and seasoning

Stir until cheese has melted and is well incorporated

Pour mixture into an oven proof casserole

Using a potato scoop, drop dollops of creamed potatoes on top of seafood in any pattern you like…

Sprinkle with remaining grated cheddar cheese

Place in oven and bake until bubbly and browned – about 30 minutes

Remove from oven and allow to cool for 5 minutes before serving.

THE LOVE: Scallops cook very quickly so don’t be concerned about the short cooking time in the skillet. They will continue cooking in the oven. Use the freshest seafood that you can find…

Thanks for reading.

  • Anonymous

    Hi Michelle:
    I want to take a moment to tell you how much I appreciate your shared recipes. I try many of them. Your musings are both delightful and poignant and often represent my own personal feelings with my two girls away at university. Than you for having the courage and generousity of heart to share. Merry Christmas.


  • Anonymous

    Hi Michelle,

    My mouth is watering just looking at this. For sure I’m going to try this one and it may become a borrowed tradition for my house at Christmas, Easter, Fall when ever.
    Thanks and Merry Christmas.


    • Wonderful!

      Have a Merry Christmas and all the best in the New Year.

  • Pingback: my best for 2012 | bite()

  • Pingback: chunky apple walnut cake with caramel glaze and food I miss | bite()